Hand Soldering vs Wave Soldering — Solder Line Quality Audit Worksheet

Hand Soldering vs Wave Soldering — Solder Line Quality Audit Worksheet

Use this worksheet alongside the main article to evaluate your own THT soldering line. Enter your production data in each step below.

Step 1: Measure Your Current THT Throughput

ParameterYour ValueUnit
THT boards per shift___boards
THT joints per board (average)___joints
Hand soldering stations___stations
Operators per station___operators

Step 2: Evaluate Solder Joint Quality

Quality MetricHand Soldering (Typical)Wave Soldering (Typical)Your Line
Rework rate2-5%0.3-1%___%
Joint temperature consistency+/- 15-25°C+/- 1-2°C___°C
Field return rate (THT-related)VariableConsistent___%
Throughput (joints/hour)60-120300-1800 mm/min conveyor___

Step 3: Calculate Annual Rework Cost

Formula: Annual Rework Cost = (Boards per shift x Shifts per year x Rework rate %) x ($ Cost per rework cycle)

ItemValue
Annual boards producedBoards/shift x ___ shifts/year = ___
Boards requiring reworkAnnual boards x (Your rework rate / 100) = ___
Cost per rework cycleOperator time ($_), consumables ($_), test re-run ($_)
Total Annual Rework Cost$___

Step 4: Compare to Wave Soldering Investment

ScenarioAnnual SavingsInvest-back Period
Reduce rework from 4% to 1%75% of current rework costAnnual Rework x 0.75 = ___ months
Eliminate 2 hand solder stations2 operators x salary + overheadInvestment / Operator savings = ___ months
Reduce field returns by 50%Field return cost x 50%Included above

Reference: Southern Machinery Wave Soldering Equipment

SpecificationS-WS350BS-WS450
Max PCB Width50-350 mm50-450 mm
Preheat Zones3 (PID, 15KW total)4 (PID+SSR)
Conveyor Speed300-1800 mm/min0-2000 mm/min
ControlPC + PLC (Siemens + Dell)PLC + HP Computer
Solder PotTitanium, 320kg capacityTitanium, 450kg capacity
Temp Accuracy+/- 1-2°C+/- 1-2°C
Running Power~2.5 kW~10 kW

For a custom line evaluation with your actual production data, contact Jason Wu: jasonwu@smthelp.com | +86 13602562576

Document S-REF-WS-001 — Solder Line Quality Audit Worksheet — Southern Machinery Sales And Service Co., Ltd.